Ralph’s Pizza & Restaurant
Nutley’s first and oldest pizzeria since 1961. I was here about 7 years ago and forgot about it, but I do remember being impressed in 2013 when I first ate there and always wanted to come back. On the rare occasion that I did pass it I would always say to myself that I have to get back there. This Friday I made it a point to drive out of my way and try it again. They say the double baked slice on the left is the one to get, but the thin plain slice is so much better, tastier and you don’t need all that bread. Not that its a lot but its twice as thick. The thin slice has cheese that goes to the end of the crust and is crispy and delicious. This is one of the best old school slices that North Jersey has to offer. They do have quite a menu and a larger dining area and party room, but the pizzeria section itself is quite small with only 3 tables holding no more than a dozen people.